Judgment vs. Accountability: What Does the Bible Really Say?

When it comes to judgment and accountability in the Christian walk, it often feels like we’re walking a tightrope. On one side, we’re told not to judge. On the other, we’re told to hold each other accountable. So… which is it?

Let’s start with two verses that are often quoted, sometimes even against one another:

“Do not judge by appearances, but judge with righteous judgment.”

John 7:24

And:

“Why do you look at the speck of sawdust in your brother’s eye and pay no attention to the plank in your own eye? How can you say to your brother, ‘Let me take the speck out of your eye,’ when all the time there is a plank in your own eye? You hypocrite, first take the plank out of your own eye, and then you will see clearly to remove the speck from your brother’s eye.”

Matthew 7:3–5

At first glance, these verses seem to contradict each other. John 7:24 appears to encourage judgment, as long as it’s righteous. Meanwhile, Matthew 7:3–5 warns us not to be hypocrites, pointing out other people’s flaws while ignoring our own.

So which is it?

The answer is… both. But maybe not in the way we expect.

---

Judging Righteously vs. Judging Hypocritically

In John 7:24, Jesus is addressing people who were judging Him for healing on the Sabbath. He tells them not to judge by appearances but to judge with righteous judgment. This wasn’t a blanket approval to go around critiquing people. He was calling out superficial and legalistic judgment, urging people to look deeper, to discern truth with wisdom, grace, and justice.

Then in Matthew 7:3–5, Jesus warns against hypocritical judgment. It’s a powerful reminder that we often project our own issues onto others. Before we call someone out, we need to examine ourselves and deal with our own sin. Only then can we clearly and humbly help someone else.

---

The Adulterous Woman: A Case Study in Grace

A beautiful example of Jesus addressing judgment is found in John 8:1–11, the story of the woman caught in adultery (connected to the end of John 7).

The religious leaders bring this woman before Jesus, demanding that she be punished according to the Law of Moses. But instead of condemning her, Jesus says:

“Let him who is without sin among you be the first to throw a stone at her.”

One by one, her accusers walk away. Then Jesus, the only one qualified to judge, says:

“Neither do I condemn you. Go now and leave your life of sin.”

Jesus doesn’t excuse her sin, but He also doesn’t shame her. He offers mercy, and in doing so, He calls her to transformation. That’s the heart of righteous judgment: truth wrapped in grace.

---

What Does This Mean for Us?

In today’s culture, especially online, judgment is everywhere. People critique what you wear, where you go, what you post, and how “Christian” your life looks.

And sometimes, in our want to defend truth or call out sin, we forget the how. We may have good intentions, but we end up casting stones instead of extending hands.

Righteous judgment isn’t about nitpicking strangers on the internet. It’s about loving correction rooted in relationship and humility.

So before we “hold someone accountable,” we should ask ourselves:

1. Do I know this person’s heart?

2. Are they someone I’m in close relationship with?

3. Am I confronting them from a place of love, not pride or frustration?

---

The Bottom Line: We’re Not the Judge, Jesus Is

There’s a difference between speaking truth in love and acting like we’re someone’s Holy Spirit.

Jesus is the only one who truly sees the heart. He judges righteously because He’s sinless, merciful, and just. When we try to take on that role, especially without the grace and humility He showed, we risk doing more harm than good.

Instead, let’s follow His example. When someone close to us is walking away from truth, we can absolutely speak up, but let it be out of love and grace. And when we see influencers, celebrities, or strangers living in ways that grieve our hearts, instead of condemning them from a distance, we can pray. We can trust that God will place the right people in their lives to speak truth in His perfect timing.

---

Final Thoughts

So, should we judge others?

Yes, but only righteously, humbly, and relationally.

Let’s stop throwing stones from afar and start embodying the grace and truth of Christ in the relationships closest to us. That’s how real accountability happens. That’s how lives change.